Applied Behavior Analysis: Difference between revisions
Fire Eider (talk | contribs) (Added more information) |
Fire Eider (talk | contribs) (Still more stuff added) |
||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
While the "new ABA" may or may not utilize punishments, they often ''withhold'' food, toys, communication devices, etc. until the child complies. It also relies on rewards, or "positive reinforcemnt"<ref>[https://www.abacenters.com/aba-therapy-positive-reinforcement/ Positive reinforcement. CW: ABA site]</ref>, which has been shown to decrease intrinsic motivation (meaning they are less likely to do the thing when there will be no reward) <ref>[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27084549/ Rewards decrease intrinsic motivation, pubmed]</ref> | While the "new ABA" may or may not utilize punishments, they often ''withhold'' food, toys, communication devices, etc. until the child complies. It also relies on rewards, or "positive reinforcemnt"<ref>[https://www.abacenters.com/aba-therapy-positive-reinforcement/ Positive reinforcement. CW: ABA site]</ref>, which has been shown to decrease intrinsic motivation (meaning they are less likely to do the thing when there will be no reward) <ref>[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27084549/ Rewards decrease intrinsic motivation, pubmed]</ref> | ||
ABA often includes "teaching" autistic kids to do stuff that is not natural to them, which leads to [[Masking|masking]], or camouflaging. This can include making eye contact, selecting appropriate topics, expressing emotions, and more. <ref>[https://www.abacenters.com/social-skills-for-children-with-autism/ "Necessary" social skills according to this ABA site]</ref> Masking has been linked to increased risk of | ABA often includes "teaching" autistic kids to do stuff that is not natural to them, which leads to [[Masking|masking]], or camouflaging. This can include making [[eye contact]], selecting appropriate topics, expressing emotions, and more. <ref>[https://www.abacenters.com/social-skills-for-children-with-autism/ "Necessary" social skills according to this ABA site]</ref> Masking has been linked to increased risk of anxiety, PTSD, and suicidality. <ref>[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31820344/ Increased suicidality, pubmed]</ref><ref>[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33593423/ Increased anxiety]</ref><ref>[https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/AIA-08-2017-0016/full/html 46% of ABA-exposed respondents had PTSD, and 47% of that group was severe]</ref> | ||
There are also ethical concerns. <ref>[https://sci-hub.se/https://doi.org/10.1353/ken.2020.0000 Ethical concerns regarding ABA]</ref> | |||
{{Comment|Maybe insert studies here refuting it, such as the Department of Defense's recent report on it, etc. Also, add a section for the Judge Rotenberg Center.}} | {{Comment|Maybe insert studies here refuting it, such as the Department of Defense's recent report on it, etc. Also, add a section for the Judge Rotenberg Center.}} | ||
Revision as of 20:40, 24 August 2022
Content warning: difficult topics. This might get uncomfortable. Remember you always have the option to stop reading if it gets overwhelming.
This page or section is a stub. Perhaps you can help add something to it? 😊
Applied Behavior Analysis, or ABA (not to be confused with the American Board Association) is called the "gold standard" for ASD by ABA, despite all the studies to the contrary.
History of ABA
History of ABA (e.g. Ole Ivar Løvaas), its development alongside Gay and Trans Conversion Therapy.
Problems with ABA
Most studies on the effectiveness of ABA is done by ABA practitioner
The autism community (mostly parents of autistic children) tend to push this "therapy" while the Autistic Community (autistics themselves) tend to vehemently oppose it.
Advocates for ABA tend to say, "That's the old ABA! The new ABA is kind and gentle!" There is a multitude of problems here, not the least of which is the ones saying this are often ABA providers/workers (aka, conflict of interest). Also, this is similar to the Moving Goalpost fallacy, where those in the "new ABA" are too young to speak up (even online), and by the time they can speak up, what they went through will be considered "old ABA".
While the "new ABA" may or may not utilize punishments, they often withhold food, toys, communication devices, etc. until the child complies. It also relies on rewards, or "positive reinforcemnt"[1], which has been shown to decrease intrinsic motivation (meaning they are less likely to do the thing when there will be no reward) [2]
ABA often includes "teaching" autistic kids to do stuff that is not natural to them, which leads to masking, or camouflaging. This can include making eye contact, selecting appropriate topics, expressing emotions, and more. [3] Masking has been linked to increased risk of anxiety, PTSD, and suicidality. [4][5][6]
There are also ethical concerns. [7]
Maybe insert studies here refuting it, such as the Department of Defense's recent report on it, etc. Also, add a section for the Judge Rotenberg Center.
Alternatives to ABA
References
- ↑ Positive reinforcement. CW: ABA site
- ↑ Rewards decrease intrinsic motivation, pubmed
- ↑ "Necessary" social skills according to this ABA site
- ↑ Increased suicidality, pubmed
- ↑ Increased anxiety
- ↑ 46% of ABA-exposed respondents had PTSD, and 47% of that group was severe
- ↑ Ethical concerns regarding ABA
